Buying tools and toolkits for classic / vintage vehicles on Ebay

Views 5 Likes Comments Comment
Like if this guide is helpful

Part 1


Buying tools and toolkits for classic / vintage vehicles on Ebay
 
I have been prompted to write these notes by the increasing numbers of fakes and forged tools and toolkits for sale on Ebay and elsewhere. (see note 3)
This is not a list of sellers who regularly sell “items of dubious authenticity” (they know who they are) but a set of basic guidelines for those enthusiasts who are trying to complete the restoration of their vehicles or machines.
If you are trying to buy the complete and original toolkit for your motorcycle / car / tractor you will be very lucky as only a few original un molested kits survive and are offered for sale, most of the kits you will see are built up from a collection of tools which are sometimes correct but more often a figment of a sellers imagination, here’s how to tell the right one to spend your money on,
 
 “buying the wrong tools is a waste of time and money”

  1. Research, join an owners club, they have vast amounts of information available.
  2. Research, use the internet, there are loads of forums and websites which deal with marques and models, there is almost always at least one tool expert.
  3. Research, you NEED a parts list or drawing, there are a lot available on the internet, they are not always correct but give a very good indication of what the tool or kit should look like and consist of, watch out for forged and altered parts list pages on a listing (it is amazing the lengths some people will go to, to give their items credence) beware of so called "complete kits" they very rarely are complete in every respect
  4. Research, Who are you buying from? Private individual or dealer, on Ebay dealers MUST be a registered business, they MUST not masquerade as private sellers, (see note 1,)  if you are buying from a private seller then they may or may not know much about what they are selling hence the need for research, if you are buying from a genuine dealer then they should know something about the items that they are selling also if buying from dealer it should be possible to talk to them on the telephone but if spending a lot of money then at least get them to verify the authenticity of the item in an email (ebay message)
  5. What are you buying? Check that the pictures of the tool or toolkit match the description and are not re used pictures from another listing or website, that any "unused" or "NOS" are not modern recently made copies, the manufacturers of these sometimes mark them with a part number (rarely found on originals, Vincent K1 and K3 being exceptions) or "MADE IN ENGLAND",  flat plate spanners are being reproduced for Triumph, Vincent and Velocette toolkits, (these tools are very good laser cut copies) a reputable dealer will mention any reproductions in his listing, another commonly forged item are the Jenbro box spanners used in the Vincent toolkit and the small Eagle Brand spanner from the same kit  (a cut down double open end spanner is a common and easily spotted item).
  6. Beware of false provenance (see note 2), just because an item was so say bought / found in the area of a vehicle manufacturer does not mean it has anything to do with that manufacturer, unless there is documentary proof its just window dressing as is the repeated mentioning of a manufacturers address, not provenance just window dresssing
  7. Ask questions of the seller, make sure you get an answer by email not on the phone just in case things go wrong, ask for extra pictures and measurements if not sure.
  8. "Its only original once" decide if you want concours, working or original, if buying a kit or part kit decide on the toolroll or case if going for a concours kit then you will probably have to settle for a very good copy of the original (do make sure that a seller knows what the original looks like and it is not a figment of thier imagination), a working or original kit is best in a roll that has some age i.e. original . The tools use the same criteria as above, concours should be as they left the factory and that does not mean "shiny shiny" very few were that, working will have a few blemishes and original should be as found, be prepared to replace half of the tools to achieve the condition that you want, most sellers seem to over polish and tart up tools, far better to let the new owner decide the level of finish.
  9. Watch out for sellers who sell the same kit time and time again, use the "completed listings" feature to check thier previous listings, be suspicious of them.
It has been said "that is takes a faker to spot a fake, otherwise how else would he know", sorry but that is a ridiculous statement, the experts on the Antiques Roadshow would take issue with it as would I, we can spot fakes/forgeries because we have years of experience and have seen and handled the genuine items many times, Sadly there are unscrupulous traders out there who take advantage of buyers lack of knowledge but do not be discouraged not all dealers are bad but all it takes is a few rotten apples to spoil the barrel. For the benefit of those rotten apples below are some definitions that they might find useful

  • Fake: an object that is made to look real or valuable in order to deceive people:
  • Forgery: Forgery is the process of making, adapting, or imitating objects, statistics, or documents with the intent to deceive or earn profit by selling the forged item. it is a criminal offence and morally reprehensible
  • Fraud: In law, fraud is deliberate deception to secure unfair or unlawful gain. Fraud is both a civil wrong (i.e., a fraud victim may sue the fraud perpetrator to avoid the fraud and/or recover monetary compensation) and a criminal wrong. If you need to report a suspected fraud then this Google this website it may be useful :- actionfraud
Here is what Ebay says about the need to register as a business (most reputable dealers are registered)
Note 1
“You should register if you:
  • sell items that you've bought to resell
  • make items yourself and sell them, intending to make a profit
  • are a Trading Assistant 
  • buy items for your business 
The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (April 2008) makes it an offence in the UK for a business to falsely represent itself as a private individual. So if you are misleading potential buyers into thinking that you are a private individual when you are in fact a business seller (ie: by not registering as a business seller with eBay), YOU will be breaking the law.”
 
 Note 2
Provenance is defined as the place where something originally came or began, or a record tracing the ownership history of certain items that helps to confirm their authenticity and value.
Note 3
The Vintage Tool Company has been trading on Ebay since 2002, we also trade at various autojumbles (including Beaulieu) and have our own specialist website, we are professional full time tool dealers and have been consultants to several auction houses where we have advised on authenticity, we sell all kinds of tools so ask if there is something that you need wether connected with Vintage vehicles or not i.e. plumbing or machine tools, chisels etc
Note 4
There is only ONE  " The Vintage Tool Company" others may TRY to imitate us by using a similar name (The Real Vintage Tool Co, Real Vintage Tool Co etc) and background colour but our reputation has been built up over 15 years, we are the original and still the best source of tools and information, remember our business details are to the bottom of each listing whereas the imitators  are nowhere to be seen other that a vague location France, Bedford, Stevenage etc but never a phone number or address even when they claim to be a business
New section ;-
Latest repro's and scams

Jaguar "Winged Logo" tyre gauges, check carefully and ask seller if genuine (Jaguar Cars Ltd are investigating miss use of thier logo as are Trading Standards) ones where engraving breaks through the chrome plating  ARE FAKES  and have been made recently, the original and genuine ones were NOT engraved (the logo was rolled onto the tubing before plating)
Jaguar screwdrivers, easy to spot but be careful if they are part of a kit

Dunlop tyre gauges engraved with anything and everything = worthless as they are not genuine
Motorcycle tyre pumps / inflators, sometimes marked with new markings, repros cost about £20 and are easy to find and spot so paying loads for a repro is silly
17/06/2016 Dunlop tyre valve tools, poorly made repros  are now being sold as genuine , easy to spot as they are so poorly made and "DUNLOP" is heavily stamped (the originals were not heavily stamped as it distorted the brass.
Here is an example of the lengths some sellers will go too, this was in reply to an enquiry about a Jaguar tyre pressure gauge,

"
"Thank you for your enquiry.  I have looked at the item on eBay (it appears that the same seller has two listing for the same item).  I can't corroborate his comment about talking to the curator at the Jaguar Heritage Museum as we did not take any phone calls last Friday on this.  Unfortunately our Archivist is not in the office this week and so I am not able to check whether we can confirm if this is the type of tyre pressure gauge that used to be supplied in the tool kit of cars back in the 1950s. 
Regards
Jonathan Partridge"
so that would make the seller a L***
Here's a new one, look closely at pictures, I have just looked at a so called Jaguar toolkit and it would seem that the seller has used pictures from his previous listings to create a "new" item, look closely and if you should want to buy the kit ask the seller why there are differences between the pictures i.e TW pliers in one picture and 287's in another , what you see is what you get?
Here we go yet again!  Dunlop pumps are the latest scam, if you buy one do check that it is a genuine old item as these pumps are still being made but the "repro" ones are being engraved with motorcycle names in an effort to fool buyers into believing that they are old and that is FRAUD
As one buyer recently said "Poor quality looks like a recycled bicycle pump"
Just read their feedback, as one said "Can't trust this guy"

Try adjusting a rear shock with this? looks similar, see below
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 2 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Try adjusting a rear shock with this? looks similar, see below
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 2 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Try adjusting a rear shock with this? looks similar, see below
Sturmey Archer and BSA 68-9462
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 2 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Sturmey Archer and BSA 68-9462
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 2 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Sturmey Archer and BSA 68-9462
<div class="fb-comments" data-href="http://www.ebay.co.uk/gds/Buying-tools-and-toolkiSturmey Archer spanner (lower left)
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page

Repro Jaguar screwdriver

These REPRODUCTION screwdrivers are being sold as genuine items, look carefully at the pictures on some listings, if the screwdriver looks like this one then it is a repro "no if's no but's" and if the seller claims otherwise then he is a
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page

Genuine Jaguar screwdriver

Compare with the repro above, this is what the genuine grip looks like
Paste a YouTube Video URL
Uploading...
Uploading...
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page

Lucas ignition tools

Repros of the  brass rivet type Lucas ignition tools are available with prices ranging from a cheap £6.30 to a "staggering" £28.99 (for exactly the same tool from the same supplier), the repros are easy to spot so do not be fooled by claims that these are original, they are not (one unscrupulous "dealer even shows old packaging in an attempt to give his repro items credibility)
Have something to share, create your own guide... Write a guide