Telescope Image Quality: Spherical or Parabolic Mirror?

Views 1 Like Comments Comment
Like if this guide is helpful
Long focus spherical mirror telescope - Avoid!
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Long focus spherical mirror telescope - Avoid!

A VERY IMPORTANT CONSIDERATION: PARABOLISATION.

IMPORTANT: This does not apply to refractors.

Small Newtonian reflectors often have spherical figured mirrors.  The mirror's shape is incredibly accurate and MUST be parabolic to bring all the rays of light to the same focus.

Manufacturers of small telescopes sometimes don't bother with this final 'figuring' of the mirror.  It's time consuming and needs special testing of the optics.  They leave it out because it's an expense they can avoid.  Their telescopes, however, because of this short-cutting, are sub-standard as a result and give awful image quality. 

They try to get around this fault by supplying long focal lengths (f9 - f12) because the difference between the spherical and parabolic mirror is smaller (But still significant!) and therefore the error will be minimised.  Some companies seem to have forgotten even this fact of physics and are producing f5 spherically figured telescopes!  Now, f5 (the focal length is five times the diameter) parabolic mirrors produce excellent bright images and can stand high magnifications on the best nights.  But, spherical mirrors of less than f10 will produce truely awful images!

Spherical focus: Some light focused at A, some at B.
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Spherical focus: Some light focused at A, some at B.

Spherical:


In the diagram: The spherical mirror gives smudged images because the focus of light reflected from different parts of the mirror is at different points (Represented by A & B).
The spherical mirror always produces out of focus blurry stars and smudged planetary images.
Parabolic focus: All light to the same focus - A.
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
Parabolic focus: All light to the same focus - A.

Parabolic:


In this diagram: The parabolic mirror brings all rays of light to the same focus and all images are pin sharp. 
A telescope with a parabolic mirror produces the best images a telescope of its size can produce. 



If you want to get the best out of your telescope, and to be  able to use the optimum magnification and have the best images, you need to have a telescope with a parabolic mirror.
For further information:
See my other guide on Diffraction Limited Optics: Good thing or bad?

130mm Parabolic view at 150x
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
130mm Parabolic view at 150x

You Get to Choose

The image at left is an aproximation of the views through a Parabolic telescope and a Spherical one.  The view is of jupiter, its moons and a double star just above.
Have a look at the two images and think about what you would want from your telescope.
130mm Spherical view at 150x
Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page
130mm Spherical view at 150x

Having thought about that, you will know the answer to the questions,
'Which would I prefer?'
or
'What type of reflector should I get?'

How Much More Will I Have to Spend for a Parabolic Mirror?


The difference in monetary outlay for a parabolic telescope can be as little as £30 for a telescope of the same diameter. 
This is a small price to pay for a telescope that will perform much, much better than one with a spherical figured mirror.

Please be careful when choosing your astronomical telescope as different models have different mirrors and it's not always obvious from the model number.  Some telescopes that are very good sellers are not parabolic telescopes and will give inferior images. 
You owe it to yourself to get a telescope that can show the best images you can to help you in your hobby.   So, please check the specification and ensure your telescope will have a parabolic mirror.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Link to an eBay page Remove
Add up to 3 more photos
Link to an eBay page

IF IN DOUBT - PLEASE ASK!



IF I CAN BE OF ANY HELP WITH YOUR SELECTION I AM MOST WILLING TO ANSWER QUESTIONS ON TELESCOPES BY E-BAY MESSAGE.






I will answer as soon as I can and it's no bother – Honestly!
I have nothing to do with SkyWatcher telescopes, neither do I sell telescopes professionally (I do sell on eBay from time to time as I upgrade).  The information in this guide is my own opinion and can be taken as my best honest advice. I have over forty years experience in astronomical observation.

Clear skies and good seeing... I hope this guide has been useful.  SuperCooper  :o)

More information? Please, Google "supercooper telescope help".



All text and images © Barry Cooper 2008-16 unless otherwise credited.
Have something to share, create your own guide... Write a guide
Explore more guides