Potentially good but...
The design is terrible. What could be a great product falls down due to some really bad design. The cut of the material means that there is excess material on the upper part of the oversee, meaning that without the press-studded band around the top, keeping the overshoe in place, the overshoe flops down and comes off the boot. This would be fine, except that a press stud isn't strong enough for how it needs to be used. It HAS to be Velcro. Every time I change gear, the elasticated press studded band pops out and the overshoe comes away, making things dangerous.
So, the overshoe needs to fit more snugly over the boot, and the band simply cannot be held in place with a press stud. There's a reason why other overshoes use Velcro.
Verified purchase: YesCondition: New