Not quite there yet.
This cable would be perfect if your MacBook never left the desk. It's easy to plug in and it detaches easily, just like the MagSafe connector it replaces.
However, if you move your laptop around with you, the little plug part is too big. It sticks out too far. I'm worried it will catch on something and damage the USB-C port or maybe make you drop the MacBook.
Overall, it's a good effort to replace the MagSafe, but not for everyone.
Verified purchase: YesCondition: New