Excellent true story,well acted about an incident in the 2nd Boer war .Edward Woodward is on top form,and the rest of the cast are excellent.How the lower ranks are scapegoated when they follow orders from above which are later denied by those in authority.The end of this film is very moving.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
A compelling film to watch. The acting is first rate and being a true story, adds to the enjoyment.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
Excellent quality, good as new
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
Very good quality
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
good account
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
This review's in two parts: 1) The DVD: I suspect that this DVD is the earlier release of the two available. What you get is the film, the chapter options, an interview with Edward Woodwardward as well as character information. There is no trailer. One drawback that I've noticed is that, if you use the chapter option, you're unable to jump back or forward to other chapters. The picture is a little more "bitty" (pixelated) than other films I have. If my DVD is not damaged, then the other release (EAN 5055019500077) might be a better option. 2) The Film: The Australian film industry made some of the very best, most realistic and endearing films about war. This is one of them. The plot is about the factual trial of three Australian soldiers serving in a non-conventional unit under the British Army. In a bid to end the Boer War, a show trial was conducted. The purpose was to appease countries that politically supported the Boers and so create an atmosphere better suited to arranging a peace settlement. The British High Command, believing this to be an easy, open-and-shut case, appointed a token legal counsel to defend the three defendants. Although the defendants' counsel was inexperienced in criminal law, rushed in, and despite the extreme prejudice of the court and the insurmountable obstacles that were put in his way, he ran rings around the prosecution's case. Far from being a courtroom only film, the events were portrayed in frequent "flashbacks" - this really makes the film work very well. Intelligent and dull alike can follow the plot. There's enough of everything less a love interest. A love interest component would only detract from the story. This is Edward Woodward at his VERY best. Bryan Brown, before his time as a Hollywood actor, is natural and convincing. As a "Supporting Actor", Jack Thompson really took the reigns and his performance was outstanding. He won "Best Supporting Actor" for his portrayal of the defence lawyer yet, as the courtroom drama unfolds, it's he who is very much a lead character, calling the shots. FallschirmWombleRead full review
Based on a true story that puts the British during the Boer War in a rather sad light. It calls into account the question regarding "The Rules of engagement" and how Political Expediency may be brought into play despite the honesty or code that the lower ranks and junior squaddies may be led to believe protects them. Some may see a parallel between this and the way the war in Iraq is being fought. Sadly their is a certain ammount of validity in this assessment. Sympathetically portrayed by Edward Woodward as Breaker Morant, a guerilla soldier, fighting under a set of rules approved of by senior command. It then shows how these Senior Officers (Field Marshall Kitchener included)effectively murder these soldiers for political appeasement. Bearing in mind particularly this is 13 years before WWI it shows the then British Government definitely not at their finest hour. A Good Film that should be watched as a matter of instruction for young officer cadets at Sandhurst.Read full review
i was pleased to find this film on ebay, this film challenges the stupidity of the General officers and of the ruling society during the late victorian era, along with other classic war films set in or around the same period. first of all we see a unit of soldiers recruited under government orders to carry out the more unpleasant side of soldiering,using the same tactics where possible as the Boer commando's,but in the end being court- martialed and in two cases shot at dawn (firing squad)because the political climate changed due to bad press, although one of the executed men did in fact commit a murder (which was never proved).
If you're not an Australian historian or militaria collector you may not know this true Boer War story which has had a MAJOR impact on the Australian military. The acting is superb and it makes you feel as if you're there. Children viewing this DVD (2001 edition)will be exposed to war scenes and sets of ethical questions they may not be prepared to cope with but with adult supervision, there should be no problem. An absolutely outstanding movie!!!
I can recommend this film as it seems as fresh today as when it was made ,what helps is there is no music which often dates a film in a bad way. The casting and location are are brilliant. enough said I think....
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best-selling in DVDs & Blu-rays
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on DVDs & Blu-rays