Featured categories
All items
2 on 1 Card: Oscar the Grouch & Slimey Buddy "Safety Pins" Sesame Street Place
£18.12
8" Igel Vintage Oscar Grouch Plush Puppet on 12" Stick Sesame Street German 1994
£18.48
50th Celebration Anniversary Pin Set Sesame Street 6 Pins Elmo Cookie Sign 2019
£66.54
Sesame Street Collectors: 1.5" T Purple Two-Headed Monster Pin S Place Classic
£15.90
New 1.5" Elmo Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place
£18.48
2XL Adult Gray Sesame Street Sweatshirt 9 Characters Elmo Grover Slimey Exc Cond
£14.78
Oscar the Grouch Season Pass Member 2024 Pin Sesame Place Street
£15.90
6 Window Pane Pins: Elmo Cookie Count Betty Lou Ernie/Bert & Big Bird Sesame St
£39.92
New 1.5" Rosita Sesame Street Pin Place Nice Happy Green Spanish Girl - Core Pin
£15.52
New Bert & Ernie In Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane Pin S Place
£16.26
12" Applause Vintage Oscar Grouch Plush Puppet Trash Can Sesame Street 14016
£10.34
2" Abby Cadabby Pin Halloween Witch Broom Dangling Pot Moon Sesame Street Place
£14.97
Vintage Chosun Bert & Ernie Plush Boxes Sesamstraat Sesame Street Ostoy Holland
£33.27
New Cute 1.5" T Herry Monster Pin Sesame Street Place Classic Rare Character
£14.78
2 New 1.5" Fancy Medallion Pins: Pals & Roomies Bert & Ernie Sesame Street Place
£31.43
New 1.25" Abby Cadabby Mecha Builder Pin Sesame Street 2025 Robot Hero
£15.90
New 1.5" Grover Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place - G Waves Out - Series 2
£18.48
Tango Season Pass Member Pin Sesame Place Street - No Date - Elmo's Dog
£15.52
1.5" Count Von Count Fancy Medallion Pin S 2 Sesame Street Place - 3 Fingers Up
£18.48
New Elmo & David Pin in Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane S Place
£17.00
Elmo & Zoe Party Parade Pin Sesame Street Place - Detailed Float Tree Flowers
£16.64
2.75" Sesame Street Character Group Stack XL Pin Place Elmo Rosita Grover 2024
£21.44
New 1.5" Sesame Place 45th Birthday Pin Party Celebration 1980-2025
£16.64
Bert Season Pass Member 2023 Pin Sesame Place Street Retired
£14.78
Cookie's Monster Land Pin Sesame Place Street - Retired Pin - Cookie Jar
£12.94
Happy Birthday To Little Slimey Pin September 2020 Calendar Sesame Street Place
£18.48
Sesame Street 1.5" T Purple Beach Two-Headed Monster Pin S Place Surfboards
£16.64
1.75" T New Bert & Ernie Beach Pin Sesame Street Place Rubber Duckie Waving
£16.64
New Cookie Monster Pin in Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane S Place
£17.00
New Baby Bear & Slimey Pin In Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane S Place
£17.00
1.5" Elmo On Purple Carousel Horse Pin Sesame Street Place 2024
£16.64
16" Elmo Pop Pillow Plush Colorful Faces Sesame Street Decor 2019 Rare Display
£25.87
1.5" New Purple Honker Pin Sesame Street Place
£14.78
New 1.5" Count Von Count in Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane Pin S Place
£17.00
1.5" Tall Greenish Blue Carousel Horse Pin Sesame Street Place ABC & Box
£18.48
New 1.5" Oscar Grouch Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place S. 2 Folded Arms
£18.48
1.75" Zoe Girl On Pink Carousel Horse Pin Sesame Street Place 2024
£16.64
New Mini Gund Best Friends Elmo & Dorothy Fish Plush Duo 2019 Sesame Street
£22.18
New 1.5" Abby Cadabby Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place S. 2 Waves Wand
£18.48
1.75" T New Pink & Green Beach Honkers Pin Share Surfboard Sesame Street Place
£16.64
1.5" Cute Pink Telly Monster Pin Sesame Street Place
£14.78
Sherlock Hemlock April 2020 Sesame Place Street Spy Good Birthday Time Calendar
£19.22
Sesame Street Collectors: 1.5" Gonger Chef Core Pin on Cookie's Food Truck Place
£15.52
New 1.5" Bert Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place - Holds Pigeon
£18.48
2.75" Sesame Place Street Group Birthday Cake Pin 40th Anniv 2020 Ltd Ed Rare
£22.18
New 1.25" Baby Alice Snufflupagus Pin Sesame Street Classic Girl Sister Snuffy
£15.52
2 Sesame Street Board Books: Beginnings Bubbles & Bert Ernie's Book of Opposites
£9.24
Oscar the Grouch Signature Dangle Pin w Apple Core & Slimey Sesame Street Place
£15.90
About us
We are Sesame Street collectors, mainly of plush. After 20+ years, we need to make room! Contact us if you're looking for a particular plush -- new or old; we may have him/her!
Seller Feedback (623)
- s***0 (133)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseVery awesome seller, quick shipping, fast replies, and the item I purchased was packaged very nicely and wrapped up to keep it safe. Item was exactly as described! I would recommend this seller and would purchase from them again!
- p***p (188)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSuper fast shipping, highly protected in the packaging, great seller if you’re looking for rare Sesame Street items for a great value overall happy. The pin is super like Super Grover and perfectly described.
- 9***l (319)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseShop with Confidence! Smooth Transaction! Fast Shipment! Packaged Well! New as Described! A+++ Seller!
- l***r (97)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseJust what I was looking for! Great price & in perfect new condition. Shipped super quick & packaged very carefully. Thanks to this seller for a most enjoyable shopping experience!
- a***_ (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipping was super fast, the item was packed well and is as described. So happy to add this to our collection. I would purchase from this seller again!
- t***y (308)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseI’m happy with my purchase, product just as described and it was packaged very well. Good price and very fast shipping. Thanks!