3.03.0 out of 5 stars
2 product ratings
  • 5stars

    1rating
  • 4stars

    0rating
  • 3stars

    0rating
  • 2stars

    0rating
  • 1star

    1rating

Would recommend0% agree

Good value0% agree

Compelling content0% agree

2 reviews

by

Misleading title! Visually incomplete with few photos; not a comprehensive reference book as promoted. Superficial overview; poorly organized.

Disappointing superficial overview; visually incomplete. NOT comprehensive as promoted; misleading title! Poorly organized.
DISAPPOINTING as a fashion research document! Few garments of each collection are presented.

Non-comprehensive & sorely incomplete. The title & presentation claim it to be more than it is. Judging by the title & back liner description, I was expecting a source for documenting every YSL haute couture garment ever presented. But only a few from each collection are shown, in this spotty overview (of clothes, only; no original design sketches are presented, with which to compare them).

Some photos were new to me; most weren't. I wasn't expecting another easily compiled re-hash of images found elsewhere.
I searched for ten specific garments from each decade, but didn't find them! Had I found one, the price would've been worth it, to document the garment. And there weren't enough other photos from collection presentations to get a feel of the visual theme of any collection.
A small written passage for each season provides a basic overview of the collections.
Visually, this is stingy. I would've preferred a simple book, even with smaller photos, showing most/ALL of the garments.

The format could be cleaner, for easy reference, with tabbed page edges for quicker reviewing & flipping through (instead of having to read the top-left of each page, to find the year/season, constantly flipping back & forth).

It's another light overview on the general themes of the collections of YSL, for the non-initiated, a well-bound slick celebration, to look great on a shelf. It's no comprehensive presentation of the designs. It's of little use to an auction house or collector.

If a young fashion student wants a big, unwieldy overview of the Yves Saint Laurent haute couture, in one place, it does that.

Drats! I wish I'd have waited to buy it second-hand.
Read full review...

Verified purchase: No

by

Great buy

Lovely coffee table book

Why is this review inappropriate?